Six Sigma Opportunity Counting

	Bookmark This Page Email This Page Format for Printing Cite This Article Submit an Article Read More Articles
	Related Tools & Articles Opportunity Definition Calculate Process Sigma Difference Between DPMO and DPPM
	Six Sigma Quick Poll Do you have difficulty defining your process opportunites and defects? Always Most of the time Sometimes Never
	Discussion Forum "There are basically three ways to count defect opportunities: DPU (Defect per Unit), DPO (Defects per Opportunity) and Defectives (Pass or Fail). Which ever method you choose is correct. In most cases, it depends on the current data collection methods. However, DPU will probably provide the most information." Counting Opportunities

By Gary Cone

Imagine the scenario.

Herman and Gary both manage processes for your company. Herman's process involves a simple matching of supplier invoices to purchase orders. Gary's process is much more complex. This process involves compliance to government regulations and requires massive amounts of data to be taken, accurately summarized and reported in several different formats to local, state, and federal agencies.

Your company is engaged in improvement activities and keeps data on reprocessed work (defects). Herman's group finds very little internal defects, but the folks responsible for accounts payable find about 5% of the work is in error, causing delays in payment to the suppliers. Gary's group finds about 20% of their work needs to be reprocessed, causing overtime to be worked to make sure reports are always filed on time with the appropriate agencies. Management reviews the results monthly and focuses on yield and labor variance.

What does management say to Herman? What does management say to Gary? In most companies Gary would be asked why he couldn't get his department to perform like Herman's. What are the implications of this type of behavior? The politically savvy types, like Herman, migrate to the simple processes. However, when we compare the work done by both groups, we find that Gary's group is ten times more error free! Has this company missed a great opportunity to learn?

This is the nature of opportunity counting and related metrics like DPMO and sigma levels. They are tools for management, not tools for the change agents and change teams. Change agents and teams only need to know current performance in the absolute simplest of terms and if the performance is improving. Management needs to know where the best processes are and where the worst processes are. We flag the best so that everyone can learn from them (rule #1 of Six Sigma - steal shamelessly all non-proprietary and non-copyrighted ideas). We flag the worst so that management will take a hard look at the issues and improve them.

Some caveats for opportunity counting (the first three could actually be caveats for Policy Deployment):

1. Whatever method is chosen, it must not conflict with other company initiatives.
2. Whatever method is chosen, it must be simple and uniform throughout the organization.
3. Companies pursuing defect reduction are also pursuing time reduction (responsiveness is the real competitive weapon, defects just get in the way of that).
4. 'Complexity' is a measure of how complicated a particular product or service is. It's doubtful that we will ever be able to quantify complexity in an exacting manner.
5. If we assume that all characteristics are independent and mutually exclusive, we may say that 'complexity' can be reasonably estimated by a simple count. This count is referred to as an 'Opportunity Count.'
6. In terms of quality, each product manufacturing or service delivery step represents a unique 'opportunity' to either add or subtract value.
7. Remember, we only need to count opportunities if we want to estimate a sigma level for comparisons of goods and services that are not necessarily the same.

That said, how do we get good guidance on how to do this? After all, the sigma metric in Six Sigma is based on an accurate counting of opportunities. If there are to be any rational discussions and comparisons of your organization's capabilities, this must be seriously considered.

Let's turn to that touchstone of clarity, the Holy Grail for all Six Sigma professionals, Mikel Harry's The Vision of Six Sigma: A Roadmap for Breakthrough. Chapter 12, Nature of Opportunities, discusses opportunities. While not exactly straightforward, there is a discussion of 'active' vs. 'passive' opportunities, where the conclusion on page 12.16 is that if we do not measure (test or inspect) the opportunity, it is not really an opportunity. So opportunities must be the things we test or inspect. Right?

Well, Motorola really touts the 'bandit' pager line in Boynton Beach, Florida, as an example of Six Sigma thinking, and one of the strongest points they make is that the product receives no test or inspection prior to being shipped to the customer. But by Mikel Harry's definition, no test, no inspection, no active opportunities, sigma level does not exist, therefore this process cannot be compared or learned from.

Anybody seeing anything wrong with this picture? This definition cannot be correct, but what is? Post your thoughts on the iSixSigma discussion forum.

"The Bottom Line" Links

BMG Upgrade Your Skills Master Black Belt Certification Get the industry's most Flexible, Robust Program for Professionals >> Find out more

VILLANOVA UNIVERSITY   Earn Your Lean, Green or Black Belt Six Sigma Master Certificate Online BOOST YOUR SALARY! *$38k more than uncertified counterparts. Learn From Industry Leaders!   START NOW

SIGMAPRO MBB, Lean Sigma, & DFSS   when experience matters most...

M O T O R O L A U N I V E R S I T Y Learn from the most experienced practitioners of Six Sigma in the world Public Training & Certification Click here to take a free Six Sigma Lesson

J URΛN   Lean Six Sigma Public Workshops Atlanta, GA - Sept 2008 Become one of your organization's 'vital few'. Get Juran Certified.

LSI Knowledge & Experience Get Your Lean Black Belt Certification -  in Denver         Register Now   -   Starts August 11!                                                     >>Learn about LodeStar Institute specials..

HOWARD UNIVERSITY Now offering Process Simulation ! 4 weeks + 1 cost saving project + 1 mentor + 1 caring instructor = 1 Marketable Certified Lean Six Sigma Black Belt

WINSTON SALEM STATE UNIVERSITY Now offering Process Simulation ! 4 weeks + 1 cost saving project + 1 mentor + 1 caring instructor = 1 Marketable Certified Lean Six Sigma Black Belt

THE UNIVERSITY OF TEXAS AT AUSTIN 2 weeks + 1 project = Black Belt Certification

. Find us on LinkedIn Join the iSixSigma Network and Connect with Other Six Sigma Pros .

. iSixSigma Live! Summit & Awards Jan 13-16, 2009 • Miami, FL Save up to $700 • Click Here! Register by August 14 .

Download the iSixSigma Toolbar for 1-Click access. Search Your Way. Everyday. Without Delay.

BEST SELLING PRODUCTS (iSixSigma Publications) 2008 VERSION! Six Sigma DMAIC Training Slides The complete Lean Six Sigma DMAIC course prepares participants to perform the role of a LSS Black Belt; covering what’s ... NEW VERSION! Process Management Training Slides The OSSS Process Management course is designed in two phases comprised of:352 Powerpoint slidesInstructor notesSlide exp... Certified Lean Six Sigma Black Belt Assessment Exam Interested in assessing your knowledge of Lean Six Sigma? Preparing for certifications? Testing your students and traine... Gage R&R Excel Template Gage Repeatability and Reproducibility (R&R) studies measure the amount of measurement variation that is attributabl... E6 Sigma DMAIC EZ: Black Belt for Service E6 Sigma is THE Six Sigma Holy Grail. The first-ever Six Sigma training and implementation software, REAL Six Sigma is a... FMEA Excel Template Need to be more preventative, prioritize risks, or brainstorm possible failures in a process or product? Use the FMEA to... NEW VERSION! Six Sigma Black Belt (DMAIC) Training Slides The OSSS Six Sigma Black Belt course is comprised of: 1,176 PowerPoint slides, Instructor notes, Slide explanations, 37 ... Sell Your Products