Six Sigma Quality Resources for Achieving Six Sigma Results
Online Training from BMG University Air Academy Six Sigma Certifications from Villanova University Click To Learn More About PremiumLinks
 Home > Tools & Templates  > Design Of Experiments (DOE) Search:
 
 for    
Publications
Marketplace
| iSixSigma
Stuff
| iSixSigma
Blogosphere
| Events
Calendar
| The
Dictionary
| Discussion
Forum
| Find
a Job
| Post
a Job
| Industry
News
| Newsletter
Signup
| Sigma
Calculator
| Online
Surveys
2008 Version! DMAIC Training Slides: 1,176 Slides + Instructor Notes and More for $99.95
iSixSigma Magazine Signup
 iSixSigma Live!  
  iSixSigma Live! Summit
  Agenda
  Registration Info
  Breakthrough Awards
 Free Newsletters!  
  Sign Up Now!
  Manage Subscriptions
  New To Six Sigma?
  Six Sigma Q&A
  Cert. Practice Test
  Problem Solving Wizard
  ISSSP Info
ISSSP Is The Official Six Sigma Society of iSixSigma
 Channels 
  Europe
  Financial Services
  Healthcare
  Military
  Software / IT
 Quality Directory 
  Best Practices
  Certifications/Awards
  Consultants
  Culture Evolution
  Methodologies
  News & Events
  Organizations
  Product/Service Guides
  Statistics & Analysis
  Tools & Templates
   DOE
   FMEA
   Glossary
   Histogram
   Pareto
   Poka Yoke
   SIPOC
   Software
  Voice of the Customer
  Free Whitepapers
 Related Topics 
  Innovation
  Outsourcing/Offshoring
  Business Process Mgt
 Quick Access 
  Help
  Search
  Advertise Here
  Article Archives
  Newsletter Archives
 User Feedback 
  Please suggest site
  improvements.
 
  [ larger form ]

Give Trainees DOE Experience with Simulated Experiments

Bookmark This Page Bookmark This Page
Email This Page Email This Page
Format for Printing Format for Printing
Cite This Article Cite This Article
Submit an Article Submit an Article
Six Sigma Article Archive Read More Articles
Related Tools & Articles
  • Discussion Forum
    "Does anybody have experience using simulation with any statistical tools? I'm curious to know how simulation can be used with statistical tools as such DOE, regression, etc."

    Contribute to this Discussion

    B
    Download Products
    y Michael Ohler

    Over the past 25 years, design of experiments (DOE) has enjoyed increasing application in manufacturing and service industries in the improvement of products, processes and service quality. The method is used to conduct experimental runs for identifying the best settings in multiparameter problems. Although experimentation can be a costly process, great potential is usually uncovered wherever engineering teams use DOE to drive improvement. Therefore, it is important that new Belts get a good grasp of this concept.

    One tool for teaching this method is simulated designed experiments. Through simulations, new Belts can get hands-on experience while learning the challenges of DOE, before they apply it to costly real-world experiments.

    Classic Teaching Methods

    Lean Six Sigma trainings typically introduce DOE as follows:

    • Simple examples for fundamental understanding
    • Case studies
    • Practical exercises using a wooden catapult or paper helicopters to show the concepts of mathematical modeling.

    After trainings using this method, engineers sometimes remain reluctant to shoulder the responsibility of conducting designed experiments in their own working environment. Because of the direct experience gained through simulated DOEs, using this method may help in overcoming that barrier.

    Design of a Function for a Simulated DOE

    Data for simulated designed experiments is produced by a model known by the instructor but unknown to students. This model should:

    • Be easy to understand so the instructor can design it quickly.
    • Be sufficiently complex such that students cannot guess it.
    • Allow for the inclusion of interaction and non-linear effects and noise.

    Such a model can be built with a function of three variables: X1, X2 and X3. The directions for completing the model are:

    1. Set f(X1, X2, X3) = aX12 + bX22 + cX32 + f0 with a global maximum (or minimum) if a, b and c are smaller (or greater) than zero. In cases where at least one coefficient has a sign different from the others, f(X1, X2, X3) has no extreme. It can be rewritten as f(X) = XTAX + f0,
        where X = (X1, X2, X3) and A has a, b and c as diagonal elements, while non-diagonal elements vanish. Then A = AT (AT is the transposed matrix of A).

    2. Shift f(X) by setting X’ = X-X0 to create linear terms.

    3. Apply a sequence of rotations to create interaction-terms: y = PX’,

    where P can be a rotation matrix using Euler angles, which represent the spatial orientation of a frame. The function then reads:

    f(y) = yTPTAPy – 2X0TPTAPy + X0TPTAPX0 + f0

    It displays linear and non-linear terms. Original function and rotation can be programmed into a spreadsheet program, where noise also can be added.

    Simulation Example

    The following description presents a DOE example an instructor employed during a training class. The area of interest to be explored is between the corner points (±1, ±1, ±1).The function is set as f(X1, X2, X3) = X12 + 2X22 + 3X32 + 10, with a global minimum of 10 at (X1, X2, X3) = (0,0,0). It is shifted to have its new minimum at (X1, X2, X3) = (0.2, 0.3, 0.4) and rotated around the z- and x-axis, and again around the z-axis by 30° each. This provides a new function:

    f(X1, X2, X3) = 10.45 – 0.45X1 – 0.24X2 – 1.84X3 – 1.08X1*X2 + 0.17X1*X3 – 1.15X2*X3 + 1.78X1*X1 + 1.53X2*X2 +2.69X3*X3.

    Between the corner points, the highest value is found to be 16.9 and the lowest 10.1 (resulting in a range of about 6.8). Now, 20 percent of that range is added as noise to the function’s values.

    Experiment

    The team decides to run a full-factorial design with one replicate per corner point and four center points, for which the instructor provides the function’s values.

    Had the center points not been included into the first run, it would have been impossible to detect curvature. The result would have been indistinguishable from a situation where the optimum is outside the area of interest.

    Now that curvature is present, the response optimizer within a typical statistical analysis software program shows the optimum is close to the center of the cube. The team decides to run a block of axial points together with two more center points.

    Output from the response-optimizer for the complete data set from 20 experimental runs is shown in the Figure 1. The minimum is found at (X1, X2, X3) = (0.19, 0.29, 0.39), close to the “real” minimum at (0.2, 0.3, 0.4).

    Figure 1: Response-optimizer Output for the Complete
    Data Set from 20 Experimental Runs

    Reviewing the Model

    Now it is possible to compare the best-fit function with the original model. Within the area of interest, the mismatch between the two is below 2 percent. This also is reflected in the match of the model parameters (Table 1).

    Table 1: Model Coefficients as Set by the Instructor (Original) and as Determined by the Team (Best Fit)
    F0X1X2X3X12X22X32X1*X2X1*X3X2*X3
    Original10.45-0.45-0.24-1.841.781.532.69-1.08-0.171.15
    Best Fit10.30-0.42-0.28-1.721.831.552.73-1.070-1.17

    Many Simulation Uses

    Simulated designed experiments offer a welcome variation in DOE trainings. Besides the application described here, teams can use simulations to:

    • Compare different DOE designs (Box-Behnken, Face-centered, Taguchi and so on).
    • Set extremes outside the area of interest (leading to evolutionary operation, where static operation of a process is replaced by a continuous and systematic slight changes in the control variables).
    • Study the power of DOE designs in the presence of different levels of noise.

    The key advantage of simulated designed experiments is the fact that data from known models can be analyzed and the result can be compared to it so that possible traps are understood before a DOE is set up in a costly real-world experimental context.

    About the Author: Michael Ohler is in charge of Lean Six Sigma trainings at a major semiconductor manufacturer. He has several years of experience as a controller, quality and project manager. He also holds a doctor’s degree in experimental physics from the Humboldt University in Berlin. Ohler also has been teaching university courses in France and Brazil. He can be reached at ohlermichael@googlemail.com.

     
    Rate This Article:  Current Rating: 3.17
      Poor    Excellent     
              1    2    3     4    5
    Copyright © 2000-2008 iSixSigma – All Rights Reserved
    Reproduction Without Permission Is Strictly Prohibited – Copyright Requests


    Publish an Article: Do you have a Six Sigma tip, learning or case study?
    Share it with the largest community of Six Sigma professionals, and be recognized by your peers.
    It's a great way to promote your expertise and/or build your resume. Read more about submitting an article.


    "The Bottom Line" Links

    1BMG
    UNIVERSITY
    .
    I
    I
    Lean Six Sigma
    Online
    I
    I
    Reduce Travel Costs
    Maximize Training Budget

    VILLANOVA
    UNIVERSITY
      Earn Your Lean, Green or Black Belt Six Sigma Master Certificate Online
    BOOST YOUR SALARY! *$38k more than uncertified counterparts. Learn From Industry Leaders!
      START NOW

    SIGMAPRO

    MBB, Lean Sigma, & DFSS

     

    when experience matters most...

    M O T O R O L A
    U N I V E R S I T Y
    Learn from the most experienced
    practitioners of Six Sigma in the world

    Public Training & Certification
    Click here to take a free Six Sigma Lesson

    JURΛN

    2009 Lean Six Sigma Public Workshops - SPECIAL OFFER!
    Register for any course before December 31st and receive 50% off any additional registrations, plus receive free consulting support! Call 800-338-7726 to register.

    LodeStar Institute

    |

    Live Lean Six Sigma Training

    Starting at $660

     WHY SETTLE FOR ONLINE? GET LIVE TRAINING AND PROJECT MENTORING FOR ONLINE PRICES.
    Finding that key person for your
    team is just a click away . . .
       
    TheJobShop

    jobs.isixsigma.com
         
    THE UNIVERSITY OF
    TEXAS
    AT AUSTIN

    2 weeks + 1 project = Black Belt Certification
    .
    Find us on LinkedIn
    Join the iSixSigma Network
    and Connect with Other Six Sigma Pros
    .
    .
    iSixSigma Live! Summit & Awards
    Jan 13-16, 2009 • Miami, FL
    Save up to $200.00 • Click Here!
    Space is Limited! Hurry!
    .

    BEST SELLING PRODUCTS (iSixSigma Publications)
    1. Certified Lean Six Sigma Green Belt Assessment Exam
      This assessment exam is useful for students interested in assessing their knowledge of Lean Six Sigma on the Green Belt ...
    2. Certified Lean Six Sigma Black Belt Assessment Exam
      Interested in assessing your knowledge of Lean Six Sigma? Preparing for certifications? Testing your students and traine...
    3. 5S Training Course
      One of the key fundamental tools of process improvement is 5S. 5S is a methodology for organizing and minimizing item...
    4. Six Sigma Black Belt (DMAIC) Training Slides
      The 2008 Six Sigma Black Belt course is comprised of: 1,176 PowerPoint slides, Instructor notes, Slide explanations, 37 ...
    5. Six Sigma DMAIC Training Slides
      The complete 2008 Lean Six Sigma DMAIC course prepares participants to perform the role of a LSS Black Belt; covering wh...
    6. Gage R&R Excel Template
      Gage Repeatability and Reproducibility (R&R) studies measure the amount of measurement variation that is attributabl...
    7. CSSBB Preparation Pack
      The CSSBB Preparation Pack includes materials for passing the Certified Six Sigma Black Belt (CSSBB) exam. This CSSBB Pr...
     
    Six Sigma AdLinks
    Rath & Strong
    Learn statistics online with Quality Trainer by Minitab
    SBTI Public Offerings, World Class MBB, Lean Enterprise
    SigmaXL: User Friendly Excel Add-ins for Statistical and Graphical Analysis
    Smarter Solutions Makes Lean Six Sigma Easier
    SigmaWorks: A complete toolbox for LSS & DFSS
    Michigan Engineering - Six Sigma Certifications
    @RISK for Six Sigma and quality analysis
    AdLinks Information


    Google AdWords
     
    Home | Discussion Forum | Event Calendar | Job Shop
    Link To iSixSigma | Rate This Page | Report A Problem | Free Content For Your Site | Submit Article For Publishing
     Terms of Service. ©2000-2008 iSixSigma. All rights reserved. v3.0lb, 2.0-A-244
    About iSixSigma · Contact Us · Privacy Policy · Site Map
    nogeo