FRIDAY, OCTOBER 31, 2014
Font Size
Topic discrimination of the measurement system?

discrimination of the measurement system?

Home Forums Old Forums General discrimination of the measurement system?

This topic contains 24 replies, has 1 voice, and was last updated by Profile photo of Allthingsidiot O Allthingsidiot O 7 years, 7 months ago.

Viewing 25 posts - 1 through 25 (of 25 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • #122477
    Profile photo of Allthingsidiot
    Allthingsidiot
    Participant
    Reputation - 0
    Rank - Aluminum

    Any  idea  on  how  to determine  the discrimination  of  the measure,ment  system?What  is  the  increment of  time?
    thanks  and  regards

    #122479

    I know Mini and JMP provide a measure of discrimination.  It usually is in the form of how many increments your measurement system can detect.  If you get a discrimination of 2 it means you can tell good and bad but no further scale is possible.  The rule of thumb is for the value to be 4 or more so at least you can make some distinction between items.

    #122481
    Profile photo of Allthingsidiot
    Allthingsidiot
    Participant
    Reputation - 0
    Rank - Aluminum

    Thank You.Please  elaborate  more to  clarify the  concept.when  to  use  it ?At  which  control  chart (XmR ?).Appreciate the  enlightenment? 

    #122482

    To get the discrimination of your measurement system you use the MSA process.  This has nothing to do with the type of control chart you are using.
    You perform the MSA, and you divide the sigma (parts) by the sigma (gage) and multiply by 1.14, then truncate the answer to an integer.
    This tells you what is called the number of distinct categories.  That is within the variation of your parts, how many groups can be discriminared by your gage.
    A number of distinct categories of 4 is considered adequate for some applications.
    If you need good discrimination for fine control, a number of distinct categoriest of 10 is considered excellent.
    Jim Shelor

    #122489

    As Jim explained, this has to do with MSA and not control charts.  It is probably a good idea to do an MSA before collecting data and plotting on a control chart.  If your measurement system has poor discrimination then the signals that might come from a control chart will have you needlessly chasing variation that can’t even be measured by your measurement system.  If your measurement system can only discriminate whole integers, reacting to points which might vary by the second decimal point, is just noise.  A nice conceptual analogy I like to use is time….one measurement system with really poor discrimination can only measure daytime and nighttime.  One slightly better might be able to discriminate by hour and an even better one down to minutes.  If you want to be able to identify time by seconds, none of the above measurement systems have sufficient discrimination.  If you want to be able to determine morning, afternoon and evening, one of the above will be sufficient.

    #122521

    Discrimination is the resolution of the measurement system to detect small changes in parts.
    Recommended discrimination : 1/10 of  6 times of the measurement standard deviation.
    ” Number of distinct categories ” will give you this measurement. Generally it has to be more than four or five to have adequate discrimination.
     
    regards
    joe

    #122518

    You can perofrm this in Minitab or JMP and see the number of distinct categories (ndc). The idela is that it should be >4.

    #122684

    Hi Jim
    You multiply by 1.41, not 1.14. Typo?

    #122719

    Yep, typo.  I hate it when I do that!

    #122724

    Hi Jim,
    I tried to reply to your e-mail but it bounced back.  Do you have an alternate?

    #122729

    OOPS!  I meant the TO line, not the subject line.

    #122728

    No alternate.
    That happens to most people because they spell my last name wrong.
    Copy and paste j.shelor@verizon.net into the subject line of the message.

    #122897

    You can use a technique called an ISOPLOT which is a special type of regression analysis (Scatter Diagram).  This is a technique developed by the late Dorian Shainin and is an excellent tool.
    The Discrimination is figured by determining the Product Variation and dividing it by the Measurement Variation.  One must acheive 6 or greater.  10 is best.

    #122899

    ISOPLOT is a crappy tool. Use real math.
    The plot is a good way to visualize a problem, but not to analyze a problem.
    People using Shainin tools are stuck in the 1970’s.
     

    #122904

    Heay maaaan,
    that ISOPLOT… It’s really groovy maaaaan.
    maaaan, I’ve got the munchies
    peace.

    #122913

    hbgb b^2,
    If you get some time could you give me a call tomorrow?
    Regards

    #123006

    The Isoplot works fine for me and our processes despite your ignorant comments.
    and your solution is?  I noticed you criticize often but have no solutions.  Please entertain us with your answer to the discrimination issue.

    #124820

    Hi Jim.  I understand your response on discrimination but am wondering why multiply by 1.14?  Thanks,  bob

    #124827

    Bob,
    There are two errors in my original post.  I said:
    You perform the MSA, and you divide the sigma (parts) by the sigma (gage) and multiply by 1.14, then truncate the answer to an integer.
    That sentence should have said:
    You perform the MSA, and you divide the sigma (parts) by the sigma (measurement) and multiply by 1.41, then truncate the answer to an integer.
    I do not know where the 1.41 comes from, but now that you asked, I am going to have to do a little study to see if I can find out.  It seems like we are picking up a sqrt(2) from somewhere.
    Regards,
    Jim Shelor

    #124828
    Profile photo of Allthingsidiot O
    Allthingsidiot O
    Participant
    Reputation - 0
    Rank - Aluminum

    It  should  be  6

    #124831

    Bob,
    The link below will take you to the derivation of the NDC equation.
    http://www.minitab.com/support/docs/Answers/Root2.pdf
    It shows where the 1.41 comes from.
    I hope this helps.
    Jim Shelor

    #124832

    Go read Wheeler’s evaluating the measurement system – it will explain it all.

    #124833

    Thanks much, your response was very helpful.  bob

    #124835

    Thanks, I will check it out.  I got another posting with a web site also.  bob

    #124847
    Profile photo of Allthingsidiot O
    Allthingsidiot O
    Participant
    Reputation - 0
    Rank - Aluminum

    Excellent  Elaboration

Viewing 25 posts - 1 through 25 (of 25 total)

The forum ‘General’ is closed to new topics and replies.

Login Form