Join other iSixSigma newsletter subscribers:
SUNDAY, AUGUST 02, 2015
Font Size
Topic What to use Z or T distribution?

What to use Z or T distribution?

Home Forums Old Forums General What to use Z or T distribution?

This topic contains 3 replies, has 4 voices, and was last updated by Profile photo of Chris Seider Chris Seider 12 years, 11 months ago.

Viewing 4 posts - 1 through 4 (of 4 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • #31962

    I have to appeal form you guys.  I was reading a lot of materials and it tells me that I should use Z distribution for hypothesis testing if:
         – Population Standard Deviation is KNOWN, sample size is either less than or more than 30
         – Population Standard Deviation is UNKNOWN, sample size is either more than or equal to 30
    I would use T distribution for hypothesis testing if:
         – Population Standard Deviation is UNKNOWN, sample size is less than 30
    Is this correct?  I am asking this because there seem to be a misunderstanding in my group.  Some are thinking that even if Population Standard Deviation is known, as long as sample size is less than 30, T distribution should be used. 
    What is correct?  Please help.  Thanks.

    #31987

    Rullean,
    I have seen the T distribution used in scenarios where there is an estimate of the population standard deviation and looking to perform inferential statistics with small confirmatory samples.  With a sample size that is less than 30, a conservative would use the T vs the Z since there is some added buffer in the wider tails of the T.  My recommendation would be to run both distributions and see how comparable the results are. Utilizing a Z vs T distribution results in a higher likelihood of committing a Type I error.  At the same level of significance, barring large sample sizes 30+, the critical value for the Z will be less than the corresponding T.  Another factor to consider is what is the alternate hypothesis (e.g. nondirectional vs. directional)  this will also have a huge impact on the results of your analysis.
    Regards,
    Erik 

    #31994

    The rule is simple:
    If the population standard deviation is known, use the z-distribution.
    If the population standard deviation is estimated using the sample standard deviation, use the t-distribution.
    It so happens that the t-distribution tends to look quite normal as the degrees of freedom (n-1) becomes larger than 30 or so, so some users use this as a shortcut.

    #32004

    Your question can be answered in two ways. 
    It depends on what statistic you are attempting to delve into.  It is difficult to determine what % of products would have a value of X or above–an individual distribution (shown as Z).  Note the t distributions assume a minimum df = 1, meaning an average of 2 items.  I would use a Z distribution if I wanted to know what % of items would be above some value assuming I had enough data (samples > 30) to approximate the population. 
    If you are comparing means and need to decide between the Z and t distributions, it does not matter if sigma (greek) is known or not if the sample is large enough in each group, greater than 30–you can use either Z or t because they become similar enough past n = 30.
    I quote “Introduction to Business Statistics” by Kvanli, Guynes, and Pavur (4th edition) which says on p.250 “Remember, however, that a more accurate confidence interval is always obtained using the t table when the sample standard deviation (s) is used in construction of this interval.
    I hope this helps.
     

Viewing 4 posts - 1 through 4 (of 4 total)

The forum ‘General’ is closed to new topics and replies.

Six Sigma Certification Online
Lean Six Sigma Green Belt and Black Belt Certification
Six Sigma Statistical and Graphical Analysis with SigmaXL
BMGI LSS Training & Certification. Learn more!
Lean and Six Sigma Project Examples
Six Sigma Online Certification: White, Yellow, Green and Black Belt

Login Form