MONDAY, JUNE 25, 2018
Font Size
Topic Benefit Calculation

Benefit Calculation

Home Forums General Forums Methodology Benefit Calculation

This topic contains 7 replies, has 4 voices, and was last updated by  Chris Seider 1 week, 4 days ago.

Viewing 8 posts - 1 through 8 (of 8 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • #706067 Reply

    A project gave us the following outcome (unit=minutes):
    PRE PROJECT
    Mean: 15, Median: 11, Std Dev: 12

    POST PROJECT
    Mean: 10, Median: 10, Std Dev: 7

    When we have a normal distribution, we take the difference in mean, annualize it, and multiply it with the headcount to get the annual person hours savings. What would you suggest in this case considering it is non-normal and there is a substantial change in std dev?

    #706073 Reply

    The average works since $ are related to actual $ spent which is number of folks….mean works mathematically better and try and get any finance guy to use a median.

    Think of this. If the average weight of gold put on a circuit board was X grams and it was reduced by 10% or to a total of 0.9*X, then the savings is 0.1*X*($/unit of mass)*# of units–independent of the median even if was a non-normal distribution.

    #706120 Reply

    Prasenjit Guru
    Reputation - 15
    Rank - Aluminum

    If due to higher Standard deviation Spread goes outside USL and LSL you can use reduced standard deviation as reduction of number of defect and can be converted into saving

    #706150 Reply

    @mrinal222 Chris Seider gave you a good suggestion if you want to do labor hours. The problem with labor hours as a general measure doesn’t mean there was an actual dollar savings. If I have 2 people doing a job and after I do some improvements I need 1.5 people then there is no dollar savings (particularly in the eyes of an accountant) because I still need 2 people. This leads to the discussion of FTE’s (Full Time Employees).

    Just my opinion

    #706151 Reply

    @cseider Appreciate your prompt response. I think I get your answer only partially. In the gold example, when you consider a sample to get the mean weight, suppose you have one data point with an extreme value. That data point is very likely to skew the mean. The mean will not remain representative anymore, right? Does it still remain valid? It will if we do not consider the outlier points though.

    #706153 Reply

    @Mike-Carnell Thanks for your response. I have a different take on the subject. Theoretically, FTEs could be broken down into many units. If I save 0.5FTEs, I can get him/her to do a job for which the organisation may have had to hire an additional resource. That’s cost avoidance. If I had a job that required half a resource’s time and the other staff members didn’t have any bandwidth,I’d have to hire a new resource.The savings of.5 FTE can help here.

    #706165 Reply

    @mrinal222 You may have a different take on FTE’s but you are going to have a difficult time selling it to anyone from accounting that needs to sign off on what you claim for benefits. “Soft Benefits” are like a footnote nobody reads.

    I will guarantee you that if for any reason you are audited by a major accounting firm it won’t fly as a benefit.

    #706168 Reply

    @Mike-Carnell brings good point on FTE’s.

    One must always use the mean–remember your savings per (part) is the total change in the input (cost) divided by the total pieces/processes made times the cost/input.

    I used to think hard about using medians for savings for non-normally distributed problems solved but the math doesn’t work out AND try getting a finance guy to use medians in their benefit calcs.

Viewing 8 posts - 1 through 8 (of 8 total)

Register Now

  • Stop this in-your-face notice
  • Reserve your username
  • Follow people you like, learn from
  • Extend your profile
  • Gain reputation for your contributions
  • No annoying captchas across site
And much more! C'mon, register now.

Reply To: Benefit Calculation
Your information:






5S and Lean eBooks

Six Sigma Online Certification: White, Yellow, Green and Black Belt

Six Sigma Statistical and Graphical Analysis with SigmaXL
Six Sigma Online Certification: White, Yellow, Green and Black Belt
Lean and Six Sigma Project Examples
GAGEpack for Quality Assurance
Find the Perfect Six Sigma Job

Login Form