iSixSigma

Request for help (quntative estimation of two sampes

Six Sigma – iSixSigma Forums Old Forums General Request for help (quntative estimation of two sampes

Viewing 10 posts - 1 through 10 (of 10 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • #36566

    Lee
    Participant

    Dear All, please help
    Does anyone know how to estimate the differance in means of two sets of samples.
     For example, if we have tested new device in technology process, how can we estimate the differance in average time spending for  this process if we have two sets: 1-st is the time for process (averaging value for each hour ) during 1 week before deployment of new device and 2-d is the same one after staring device usage.
    Thanks in advance.
    Regards
    Eugene

    0
    #105857

    Renato
    Participant

    Depending . This is a general answer based on the description provided
    You can use t-test or Anova analysis.
    Before doing that you must take a look at the normality test (anderson-darling) and look to the graphics looking for some cyclic behavior. (use one column for “before” data , and another for “after” data…)
    Maybe you would need to use a paired t-test …
    these tests provide you easily ( in minitab) the estimated difference among 2 means in the results window. The significance depends on the p-value .
    BR
     
     

    0
    #105858

    Ritz
    Member

    Eugene,
    Paired-T test.

    0
    #105905

    Lee
    Participant

    Renato, thank you for help at first.
    But I still have some question, I just started to learn  statistics, so the question.
    I use ANOVA single factor annalysis, as I am aware, the rations between F and F critical determine the statistical significans of the two means, but it does not answer the question about in what times it less/bigger. I am interested in quantative estimation.
    You say the p-value represent the quantative estimation, does not it?
    Could you tell me about this, please?
    Thank you again
    Regards
    Eugene

    0
    #105906

    Lee
    Participant

    Ritz, thank you for help .
    But I still have some question, I just started to learn  statistics, so the question.
    I use ANOVA single factor annalysis (it is the T-test also?),  but it does not answer the question about in what times it less/bigger. I am interested in quantative estimation.
    Can you explain what factors are responsible for quantative ratios between means?
    Thank you again
    Regards
    Eugene

    0
    #105916

    Ritz
    Member

    Eugene,
    First: You are attempting to determine if sample-1 is different from sample-2.  In comparing only 2 means, the t-test is the appropriate test, not ANOVA (F-test). 
    Second: Your samples seem to be dependent, essentially indicating that the only change to the technology process is the new device.  If so, then the paired t-test is the correct test to use for this situation.  If you are using Minitab, but the “before device installed” hourly average time data in column 1, and the “after device installed” hourly average time data in column 2.  You will want to check for normality before using the paired t-test.  If the data are not normal, use the nonparametric alternative (sign test or signed rank test).
    Third: Assuming normal data and using the paired t-test, a p-value below 0.05 indicates a significant difference between the two sample means.  Understanding which sample has a larger mean is as simple as looking at the results table — the sample means are given. 
    Fourth: Assuming all of the above (no confounding process changes, normality, set-up and run test correctly, etc.), you can state (given a level of confidence, typically 95%) that the device caused a significant change in process mean.
    Hope this helps provide some clarity – please provide further clarification of what you are looking for if this post does not help.
    Regards.
    Ritz

    0
    #105969

    Lee
    Participant

    Ritz, Thank you a lot for this complete information!
    Yesterday I have improve my statistic lnowlrge and today I am understand you entirely.
    I have additional quaestions, why ANOVA is inappropriate test, I mean if befor testing I phave berformed the Anderson-Darling test then ANOVA is suitable, is  not it?
    And I wil try to use your goodness one more time. You see I am from Ukraine and have no softwares tatistical tools, so I rty to eleborate the algorithm and implemented it by myself. So, Can you suggest me some links to the web sights with such detailed explanation?
    Thank you a lot, you have helped me very greatly.
    Regards
    Eugene
     

    0
    #106602

    Ritz
    Member

    Sorry for the delay, Eugene.  Took some time off.  Nice to hear from a fellow Ukranian (my Father’s side came to America in c.1900)
    It isn’t so much that the ANOVA is inappropriate – it is essentially a t-test as well.  ANOVA is a robust test — it is likely to pick up significance in your case.  The question is more of precision of testing methods – the paired-t test is more appropriate since your samples are dependent on each other.  ANOVA and 2-sample t-test use an assumption of independence.  ANOVA and 2-sample t-test will yield the same result when comparing 2 (and only 2!) samples.
    A few websites I have found useful for knowledge and reference are:
    http://davidmlane.com/hyperstat/
    http://www.statsoft.com/textbook/stathome.html
    http://stat-www.berkeley.edu/users/stark/SticiGui/Text/index.htm
    I would recommend purchasing a stats software tool when you have the money and opportunity – Minitab is commonly used in 6-Sigma deployments, but Jump, Statistica, SPSS, are also good packages.  At minimum, Excel has an ANOVA and t-test module you can load in for free…go to “tools” menu, select “add-ins” and look for the “data analysis” add-in.
    Good luck to you.
    Regards,
    Ritz

    0
    #106603

    Lee
    Participant

    Ritz, hello.
    Thank you for your information. It is very useful for me.
    I am using excel data analysis tool now, so thank you for your advices.
    It is very pleasent to hear that there are some connections between you and Ukraine.
    So I will rise my level in statistics.
    Have a nice day!
    Regards
    P.S. If you have wish to visit a Kiev please let me know, I hope I will help you with this.

    0
    #106605

    Lomax
    Participant

    Hi everybody,
    Personally, I use the following for test between two  samples:
    Comparison of Means::: If sample size <30 – t test . else. z-test
    Comparison of variances :: F Test
    These are based on statistical equations and are quite robust. I have made them into easily usable excel file – But do not know how to attach it here. If anybody is interested, can write to me at [email protected] – provided of course, you promise to help me in future if I have a technical problem and you are in a position to help ;-)
    Neil
     

    0
Viewing 10 posts - 1 through 10 (of 10 total)

The forum ‘General’ is closed to new topics and replies.