Font Size
Topic ROI


Home Forums Operations Finance ROI

This topic contains 8 replies, has 7 voices, and was last updated by  Frank Herrera 2 years, 7 months ago.

Viewing 9 posts - 1 through 9 (of 9 total)
  • Author
  • #166856 Reply

    Hi — seems like during this tough economic time, my company has become a real stickler for showing ROI on any improvement project we start. I know how to calculate traditional ROI, and within that, I know how to calculate the cost-component fairly well — but my challenge is figuring out the “return” component (or the value the project will potentially give us in the long-run). Some projects are pretty easy, but some are complex so I was wondering if anyone could share some methods that work for them.


    #166860 Reply

    There was an article on ROI posted on the website a few weeks ago and should be easy to find. I do share your interest in finding new ways for costing — might have to dig deeper.

    #202045 Reply

    Want to know the calculation? Read wikipedia post on this with easy calculation method.

    #202073 Reply

    @Sebs1977 – I’m guessing the problem is not in calculating improved output, or even throughput, but rather labor savings. This is always tricky, as you don’t save anything until there are fewer feet coming in the door. Thus, labor savings that reduce less than one FTE are not “hard” savings. And then, even those that do reduce more than one FTE are not actualized savings until that FTE is no longer allocated to the activity (preference is to find new value adding activities, but sometimes it is just reduction of headcount).

    #202113 Reply

    I’d advise you to work with your financial folks. They aren’t going to just accept a model for savings from someone who’s not familiar with the corporate standards but there’s NOTHING wrong with presenting a potential model.

    #203119 Reply

    @Sebs1977 Get hold of some information on Activity Based Costing (ABC). It will help you understand how to build cost models for your projects. If you take a strong run at building your own model and then take it to your finance people like Chris suggested you will be amazed at how much better you understand your business.

    Just my opinion.

    #203157 Reply

    Don Strayer
    Reputation - 979
    Rank - Copper

    Finance experts today are more interested in IRR (Internal Rate of Return) than simple ROI. IRR includes NPV (Net Present Value) in the calculation. This allows comparison of investment in the proposed project to other potential investments. If you aren’t a finance expert do not try to do these calculations yourself. You can easily find the formulas and do the calculations but you’ll be torn to bits when you present them unless there “hard” savings. Assumptions such as the benefit of improved quality or reduced cycle time will not suffice if your management doesn’t embrace these same assumptions.

    #208925 Reply

    Don’t go for overkill. The best ideas are those which can be explained to a layman. If you know the business, the risks to the business and the process, try to articulate the ROI best as you can in the manner you understand. Once the concept is clear, the financial wizards can present in any which way, they desire.

    #501863 Reply

    Frank Herrera
    Reputation - 36
    Rank - Aluminum

    Hello Seb,
    Did you experiment with the long term net present value of the cash flows indicated in your roi calculations. Calculate the internal rate or return and compare it with your NPV and that should give you something solid to work with.

Viewing 9 posts - 1 through 9 (of 9 total)

Register Now

  • Stop this in-your-face notice
  • Reserve your username
  • Follow people you like, learn from
  • Extend your profile
  • Gain reputation for your contributions
  • No annoying captchas across site
And much more! C'mon, register now.

Reply To: ROI
Your information:

5S and Lean eBooks

Six Sigma Online Certification: White, Yellow, Green and Black Belt

Six Sigma Statistical and Graphical Analysis with SigmaXL
Six Sigma Online Certification: White, Yellow, Green and Black Belt
Lean and Six Sigma Project Examples
GAGEpack for Quality Assurance
Find the Perfect Six Sigma Job

Login Form