Six Sigma is not for the faint-hearted. It is a challenging strategy to master and execute in for-profit businesses, but even more difficult in the healthcare industry with constraints such as high barriers between the different professional groups, the lack of funds, understaffed and overworked employees, and individualized work procedures that are rarely managed or controlled. But the rewards are worth it, and its benefits can serve healthcare providers in many ways. Primarily, Six Sigma processes can deliver better care to more people at a lower cost.
Watching the popular television show “ER,” it is easy to see how one could think of hospital life as the saga of valiant doctors struggling against overwhelming odds, tidal waves of patients, flinty-eyed administrators and a cruel society to save the lives of patients in dire need. All the while, steady nurses soldier on to provide what solace they can to the young physicians and needy patients. If only life were so simple. Out of sight and out of mind, in this television version of an ER, are all those others who, in real life, make patient care possible: the labs, radiology departments, ORs, laundry, medical supplies, pharmacies, and so on.
Healthcare, while totally dependent on physicians, is also a complex web of interconnected and interdependent processes. If one process fails, the entire edifice can collapse. To illustrate, let’s go back to our TV drama: imagine one of those GSWs (“gun shot wounds”) brought to the ER by ambulance. The patient is strapped to a gurney, rushed into the ER with IVs hanging, and people shouting orders, and is then lifted onto a bed. Young Dr. Carter takes one look and orders 2 units of blood, a CBC (Stat) and a chest X-ray. Now what? What if the blood does not get to the ER? What if it is incorrectly typed and cross-matched? What if the turnaround time for a stat CBC is an hour instead of 10 minutes? And by the way, how does one get a chest X-Ray on a patient bleeding in the ER? For that matter, where does young Dr. Carter get his sutures, scalpels, linens, antibiotics, and IVs? On television none of these things matter. We break for a commercial and things just happen, but not in the real world.
So what does this have to do with Six Sigma? Four forces are converging to make the delivery of healthcare in the years to come more difficult than it has ever been:
The confluence of increased demand, decreased funding, shortages of staff, and increased litigation creates a compelling case for change. Six Sigma might be one of the most compelling strategies to address these issues.
Six Sigma is shorthand for a discipline that allows any business to design, improve and manage its processes so that they perform at their highest possible levels. High levels of performance mean high volume, fast turnaround times, very few errors or defects and low cost. Effective and efficient processes also help to reduce staff turnover and increase retention by eliminating one of the main causes of high turnover – cumbersome and complex procedures and routines. And finally, Six Sigma promises to overcome the challenge of all professional disciplines – leveraging effective techniques and methods across the board – and dramatically decreasing medical errors.
Six Sigma is a synonym for a process improvement strategy that focuses on eliminating defects. What is a defect? Everything that does not meet customer requirements – staying in the hospital one day longer than required, a mistake during a surgical procedure, or excess wait time when being admitted to the hospital. A process capable of Six Sigma performance is equivalent to the occurrence of 3.4 defects per million opportunities – a stretch goal for virtually every business process. Airlines are one of the few businesses that have mastered this level of quality when it comes to having an equal number of takeoffs and landings. However, when it comes to on-time departure, their performance is less impressive. By measuring the capability of a process to meet customer needs, Six Sigma provides a framework to identify processes that could benefit from improvements.
But Six Sigma is not only about applying a rigorous measure based on customer needs – it is the application of powerful statistical techniques coupled with a rigorous approach to identify the root cause of the problem that enables teams of subject-matter experts to eliminate defects and achieve breakthrough results. The following case provides an example of how the rigor of Six Sigma can help improve a typical hospital process.
However, the benefits of Six Sigma extend far beyond reducing cost or increasing efficiency:
Six Sigma is not for the faint-hearted. It is a challenging strategy to master and execute in for-profit businesses, but even more difficult in the healthcare industry with constraints such as high barriers between the different professional groups, the lack of funds, understaffed and overworked employees, and individualized work procedures that are rarely managed or controlled. But the rewards are worth it, and its benefits can serve healthcare providers in many ways. Primarily, Six Sigma processes can deliver better care to more people at a lower cost. But Six Sigma processes can also help to attract and retain staff. Healthcare is a super-ego profession. Every provider feels compelled to do their best for the patients. Sub-par performance is a nightmare for doctors, nurses, managers, technicians and others in the profession. No one wants to work in sub-standard processes. To the contrary, people are drawn to systems where care is excellent. While sub-standard processes create a downward spiral of poor care, lessen the ability to attract and retain staff and increase cost, superior processes create an upward spiral of excellent care, strengthen the ability to attract and hold staff, and lower expenses.